Germany’s Energiewende aims to make baseload power obsolete

In a December 2015 article in Forbes, William Pentland seeks to answer the question “What is so revolutionary about Germany’s Energiewende?”

Mr Pentland begins:

Germany’s energy revolution has become the perennial punching bag of American energy policy.

In particular, American pundits have lampooned German Chancellor Angela Merkel’s decision to phase out the country’s fleet of nuclear reactors by 2022 as at best naïve and at worst delusional. Germany’s generous renewable energy subsidies have also provoked the ire of conservative groups.

Germany’s energy policy – the Energiewende or Energy Transition – has pushed up electricity prices, eroded the profitability of Germany’s largest power companies and created a clutch of operating challenges that could ultimately threaten the central power grid’s reliability.

And yet as the Energy Transition emerges from the chaos of its beginning, it is becoming increasingly clear that American critics of the Energiewende are missing the forest for the trees. The critics are not wrong. Germany’s renewable subsidies have pushed up electricity prices. It is also true that Germany’s policies requiring natural gas and nuclear plants to mitigate the grid impacts of variable resources like solar and wind have massively eroded the economics of baseload power plants.

And Mr Pentland concludes:

So it goes with Energiewende. So what is it that makes the Energiewende unique? It wants to make baseload power obsolete. This ambition distinguishes Energiewende from every other large-scale energy initiative underway in the world.

The Energiewende has galvanized a gale of economic destruction. What American critics of the Energiewende have yet to appreciate is that the Energiewende’s destruction is of the decidedly creative ilk.

(Emphasis added.)

Joseph Schumpeter is cheering.

Read the article.

Electricity Market 2.0: An electricity market for Germany’s energy transition“.

Feed-in tariffs are not state aid“.

About feed-in tariffs.

And From the Energiewende site:










Hermann Scheer was the key driver of feed-in tariffs in Germany and of the Energiewende.

About ecoquant

See Retired data scientist and statistician. Now working projects in quantitative ecology and, specifically, phenology of Bryophyta and technical methods for their study.
This entry was posted in adaptation, Anthropocene, Arnold Schwarzennegger, bifurcations, Bloomberg New Energy Finance, BNEF, bridge to somewhere, Buckminster Fuller, citizenship, civilization, clean disruption, conservation, consumption, decentralized electric power generation, decentralized energy, demand-side solutions, destructive economic development, disruption, distributed generation, Ecology Action, efficiency, EIA, electricity, electricity markets, energy, energy reduction, energy storage, energy utilities, engineering, Epcot, feed-in tariff, FERC, fossil fuel divestment, grid defection, Hermann Scheer, Hyper Anthropocene, investing, investment in wind and solar energy, ISO-NE, Joseph Schumpeter, liberal climate deniers, local generation, marginal energy sources, mesh models, microgrids, optimization, planning, politics, public utility commissions, PUCs, rate of return regulation, rationality, reasonableness, regime shifts, regulatory capture, Sankey diagram, solar domination, solar energy, Solar Freakin' Roadways, solar power,, Spaceship Earth, sustainability, the energy of the people, the green century, the value of financial assets, Tony Seba, wind energy, wind power, zero carbon. Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Germany’s Energiewende aims to make baseload power obsolete

  1. Pingback: On supporting farms with a second stream of income | Hypergeometric

Leave a reply. Commenting standards are described in the About section linked from banner.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.