The designers of our climate

The blog … And Then There’s Physics wades deeply into the recent Monckton-Soon-Legates-Briggs paper. And, they conclude, what it is saying is that, conditional upon no feedbacks, equilibrium climate sensitivity (“ECS”) needs to be small. Except that they don’t say that explicitly, dressing it up (presumably to look important).

So why didn’t they say so in the first place?

Update, 3rd March 2015

Dr Wei-Hock Soon, co-author of the paper discussed here, defended his calculations and position, at an event sponsored by The Heartland Institute. Dr Soon’s official statement is available. [Replace by link to this page instead since the former page is now missing.] I would much rather he respond in technical detail to the critique of those calculations, releasing that as well, whether in the original journal, or through

Heartland might want to portray Dr Soon as a martyr, and, indeed, I’d prefer the discussion to be limited to the technical details. But the public does not understand technical details, and just pays attention to the cloud from a scientific dust-up. Various individuals accusing many scientists of ‘being climate alarmists’ have repeatedly done the same, trying to involve and tarnish as many scientists as they can. It may be true that Dr Soon’s case and publication is a “troll”, something which Greenpeace and others have been suckered into exploiting. After all, he has three other co-authors on the paper, fiction writer Monckton, the ever-religious Legates, and the ever-entertaining Briggs. Briggs, for example, claims he was “being groomed to take over a spot at Lawrence Livermore lab“, a prestigous national laboratory, and was rejected because of his stance on climate change.

(Update, 2019-01-29)

The key links to Dr Soon’s statement has been removed from the Heartland Institute site linked above. I have instead replaced them with a link to Dr Soon’s standard page at Heartland.

...and Then There's Physics

Okay, I finally succumbed and actually waded through some of the new paper by Monckton, Soon, Legates & Briggs called Why models run hot: results from an irreducibly simple climate model. I did it, so you don’t have to (and believe me, it’s really not worth it). I’m not even sure I actually quite get it, since it is so chock full of stuff that doesn’t really make a great deal of sense.

I, however, think I’ve worked it out. According to their model, temperature $latex T_t$ at time $latex t$ after a change in forcing $latex Delta F_t$ is given by

$latex Delta T_t = q_t^{-1} Delta F_t r_t lambda_o (1 – g)^{-1},$

where $latex q_t$ is the fraction of the forcing due to CO2, $latex r_t$ is the fraction of the equilibrium response attained by time $latex t$, $latex lambda_o$ is the no-feedback sensitivity, and…

View original post 197 more words

About ecoquant

See Retired data scientist and statistician. Now working projects in quantitative ecology and, specifically, phenology of Bryophyta and technical methods for their study.
This entry was posted in astrophysics, bridge to nowhere, carbon dioxide, carbon dioxide capture, carbon dioxide sequestration, Carbon Tax, Carl Sagan, citizenship, civilization, climate, climate change, climate education, differential equations, ecology, economics, engineering, environment, ethics, forecasting, fossil fuel divestment, geoengineering, geophysics, humanism, IPCC, mathematics, mathematics education, maths, meteorology, methane, NASA, NCAR, Neill deGrasse Tyson, NOAA, oceanography, open data, open source scientific software, physics, politics, population biology, Principles of Planetary Climate, probabilistic programming, R, rationality, reasonableness, reproducible research, risk, science, science education, scientific publishing, sociology, solar power, statistics, testing, the right to know. Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to The designers of our climate

  1. Pingback: Stream flow and P-splines: Using built-in estimates for smoothing | Hypergeometric

Leave a reply. Commenting standards are described in the About section linked from banner.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.